Ode To Bookworms


Image by Pexels from Pixabay

I’m often annoyed when bookworms are mocked or criticized in books. Around the world, little bookworms are often unfairly ostracized and isolated from their relatives or friends due to their choice of entertainment. Being misunderstood by people surrounding you is hard enough, and being misunderstood by authors who write books for bookworms to feed on is even harder to swallow. Book reading is just a hobby, very much like skydiving, shopping, fishing, hunting, following sports. No more and no less. To be fair, we should just treat it like another innocuous pastime. However many authors consciously and subconsciously refuse to do that. When describing a character, they are very unlikely to say he is silly because of his fishing hobby or she is awkward because she skydives too much. However these authors can be very quick to combine a person’s weakness with his or her love of books. Usually an author will not explicitly say that book reading is directly connected with certain stupidity, but the two things will be put together to create a juxtaposition to imply that the two are related.

The Image of Cecil And Charlotte

E. M. Forster’s “A Room With A View” mocks bookworms left and right. It’s a story about a young English woman Lucy Honeychurch who’s engaged to marry Cecil Vyse, but a newcomer George Emerson budges in and marries Lucy instead. Cecil is described as a pedantic bookworm by the author from his first appearance to the last. Whenever he shows up, he will utter something unforgivably silly while holding a book. E. M. Forster almost holds the readers’ ears and shout into them,”look, he is so stupid and he loves books. Don’t you see the connection?” Actually in my opinion, a silly person will be silly no matter what hobby or job he or she takes. Somehow I am convinced if Cecil loves gardening or football, E. M. Forster would never dream of making the connection between his silliness and his hobby.

Lucy has an aunt, Charlotte Bartlett, who lives on the margin of the society and this story. The author describes her as a stereotypical old maid–her over-observation of good manner is ridiculous; her interest in reading romance novels is mawkish; her friendship with Eleanor Lavish, who writes silly sentimental books, is farcical and mischievous. I can hear E. M. Forster say, “Look, both Eleanor and Charlotte are old and silly. One writes silly books and the other reads them. Don’t you see the connection?” Actually doing chores every day is as damaging, if not more, to women as reading romance books. Not chatting enough with friends is also quite damaging. There is no reason to single out book reading (or writing) among all other activities to be connected with silliness. It is quite unfair to books. And it is also quite unfair to Eleanor and Charlotte, both struggling financially, both having gone through life with wisdom and experiences. They are not the silly women E. M. Forster wants to believe. They have a lot of worthy things to say, probably even more so than George or his father.

I wish my friend C will never read this since she loves E. M. Forster and she will certainly be offended when she reads my unflattering description of her favorite book. I love this book too, but there are certain aspects of this book that I don’t agree. Actually I have more objections, but it is unrelated with books or bookworms. It is quite off topic if I talk about them here and now.

I also want to talk about Mary from “Pride And Prejudice”, Lady Amelia in “Period Piece” by Evelyn Waugh, and bookworms in “The Public Library” by Isaac Babel. However the post is getting a little long and I want to take a rest today. So I will do it some other time, over the weekend or during next week.

(To Be Continued)

24 thoughts on “Ode To Bookworms

  1. It seems that bookworms are very often criticised in books- ironically. I think of my favourite book Pride and Prejudice where the youngest sister was criticised for being an introverted bookworm.

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Yes, that is true. Mary is the girl seriously vilified in P&P. It is quite unfair. I tried to write about that too in the post, but it gets too long. So I decided to do it later, but I haven’t get to it so far.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. Yeah absolutely- Mary is constantly looked down upon and shown as abnormal just because she likes reading and is introverted. I look forward to reading your thoughts about her character.

        Liked by 1 person

        1. Thank you for the encouragement. Yes, Mary is quite unfairly treated. She might be a little nerdy and a little awkward on the outside, but the author didn’t give her any chance to display her inner world. I definitely will write about this…hopefully soon. I am so disorganized…

          Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s so true. How can book reading change people’s look? It is so ridiculous. However some believe in these stereotypes and enjoy reading about them so that they can immerse in their own echo chamber.

      Like

  2. There are many stereotypes that are so silly and have no logical basis.
    I think certain (intellectual) habits are looked upon as nerdy because many don’t have the IQ for that and can’t relate. Let the fools fume. Haha. 🙂

    Liked by 1 person

  3. I admit it. I am a bookworm! And proud to be! Totally obsessed with books. I love books and I not only enjoy the reading and the bookstore browsing, my book shelves (colour coordinated 😁) are a pleasure to look at. Sad that intelligent people are constantly being put down just because they might be different … as in reading more instead of hanging in front of the PC playing mindless games 😉

    Liked by 1 person

    1. That’s soooooooooo true. Bookworms need to be more assertive and stop feeling guilty when reading books. And you know the Asian immigrant community here consists of engineers, scientists, and businessmen. None of these people like books very much. It’s all about work, money etc. I mean back home there are people who love art, literature, movies, cartoons. I mean variety of people, among whom one can find like-minded interests, but here one just can’t. It’s a skewed environment and one can only live with a big sigh.

      Liked by 1 person

  4. An excellent read. Looking forward to the continuation. Although bookworms are sometimes unfairly stereotyped, some of the other activities you mention (e.g., shopping, fishing, watching sports) lend themselves to unflattering characterizations in writings as well.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Such an interesting observation! Where I live, “nerd” or “bookworm” is supposed to be a compliment rather than criticism, no matter who it comes from. There are many stereotypes associated with bookworms such as weird, lonesome and introverted. As far as I have observed, that is often quite true. This is such an intriguing observation! 👌

    Liked by 2 people

    1. So true. Our Asian psyche admires bookworms and nerds. And it is a compliment. You are absolutely right about it. Hahaha, you know I’ve never really thought about stereotypes so often until recently, but now I often think about them–how it all started and how to deal with it. Life is interesting to read.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Geoff Stamper Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s